Madden NFL Football Review
Madden NFL Football Box Art
System: 3DS
Dev: Electronic Arts North Carolina
Pub: Electronic Arts
Release: March 27 2011
Players: 1
Screen Resolution: N/A

The lack of content really is the biggest problem with the game, and I would almost be ready to accept the game as it is, if it weren't outshined directly by its DS predecessor. The last Madden game to be on the DS (which was released nearly two years ago, if anyone's counting) featured modes similar to the offerings on Madden NFL Football, but at least it had the courtesy to include online multiplayer. Seeing as how multiplayer is such a big part of the 3DS experience (with StreetPass and the new persistent online friends system), you would think Madden NFL Football would at least have a local multiplayer option if they couldn't implement anything online. But alas, this football game is one you are doomed to experience alone.

Madden NFL Football Screenshot

Visually, Madden NFL Football is disappointing as well. Player models all suffer from strange proportions, and animations are frequently awkward and don't always make sense. For instance, after making a tackle one of my players made a strange bridge-like movement over the tackled player's body before returning to the field via teleportation. Though these animation issues are humorous at first, they are all too frequent and show a general lack of polish in the game.

The 3D in the game works well enough, but it includes far too many "gimmick" shots. We get that when a player throws a ball it looks like it's coming towards you. The novelty has worn off. I'd much rather have 3D visuals that enhance the gameplay and give me a sense of really "being there" on the field. The 3D visuals also have some of the highest contrast I have encountered in a 3DS game, and if you have borderline sensitivity to 3DS images, Madden NFL Football will push your eyes to their limits. Ironically, the best part of the game's visual design is the loading screens, which feature some cool 3D images of football stadiums.

Advertisement

Madden NFL Football is a very simplistic game. I wonder if the game was rushed to market just so the next iteration of Madden, when it comes this fall, can make a better showing on the 3DS. If this is the case, and this initial offering of Madden was just released now so that the inevitable release of Madden 12 will be far enough away for football fans to feel good about purchasing it, then this is a sad day for gaming. Madden NFL Football feels like an over-long demo, and its $40 price tag is a hard thing to swallow for the amount of features that are present in the game. If there was more to do in the game, better production values, or even just a multiplayer mode or two, this Madden NFL Football could have been decent. But as it is, the experience is far too thin and definitely forgettable, which is perhaps what EA is banking on.

By Amanda L. Kondolojy
CCC Senior Contributing Writer

RATING OUT OF 5
RATING DESCRIPTION
3.3
Graphics
Visuals in-game are satisfactory, but jerky animations and too many "gimmick" shots make this one of the least-impressive 3DS titles I've played.
3.4
Control
Controls are easy to use, and very simplistic.
2.4
Music / Sound FX / Voice Acting
Crowd noise and commentary get repetitive fast.
2.3
Play Value
The single-play and season modes are fun, but don't provide any lasting value beyond a few hours' gameplay.
2.6
Overall Rating - Average
Not an average. See Rating legend below for a final score breakdown.
Review Rating Legend
0.1 - 1.9 = Avoid 2.5 - 2.9 = Average 3.5 - 3.9 = Good 4.5 - 4.9 = Must Buy
2.0 - 2.4 = Poor 3.0 - 3.4 = Fair 4.0 - 4.4 = Great 5.0 = The Best

Game Features:

  • NFL Football In 3D - Experience all the drama of the NFL in 3D as Madden NFL Football brings your favorite players and all thirty-two teams and stadiums to life like never before!
  • Football for Everyone - With three types of playcalling, Madden NFL Football adapts to you. The GameFlow feature automatically selects the best play for the situation based on authentic NFL team gameplans. Use Arcade playcall for more control over plays or Classic to experience the full depth of your favorite team's authentic playbook.
  • Back to the Neighborhood - Madden NFL Football puts a new twist on an old style of competition. Take your game back to the neighborhood with high-scoring, fast-paced 5-on-5 action. No penalties, no play clock, just action-packed football where the first team to score a set number of touchdowns walks away with ultimate bragging rights!
  • Call Your Shots - Unleash the amazing power of the Nintendo 3DS Touch Screen to draw up your own plays on the fly! Whether on offense or defense, you can create the ultimate audible at the line of scrimmage.

  • Screenshots / Images
    Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge Madden NFL Football Screenshot - click to enlarge

    X
    "Like" CheatCC on Facebook